Records Committee
Review List Changes

   Results  
 Deadline --24 Sep 2025 
 

 

 

 
Proposals by Bryant:  with discussion and other proposals by Jeff and Mike --
Initial Proposal and following discussion

 

 
Proposals

Changes in Review Species List.

 

 
        1. Add  Red Knot   -   Exclusions:  Great Salt Lake                 9 Acc

        2. Add Inca Dove to the Review List                                 9 Acc

        3. Add Lesser NighthawkExclusion:  Washington Co.         9 Acc

        4. Add Verdin  -  Exclusion:  Washington Co.                       9 Acc

*****
Please vote for or against BOTH options in the following section - alternatives by Mike)
  
     5. Add Black-tailed Gnatcatcher -   Exclusion: Washington Co.           5 Acc, 4 Rej
                                   OR
    
  5a.   "         "              "              - Exclusion:  Beaver Dam Slope/west    4 Acc, 5 Rej
                                                                                                                    side of Beaver Dam Mountains

      6.  Add  Brown-crested Flycatcher - Exclusion: Washington Co.             5 Acc, 4 Rej
                                  OR
  
   6a.  "         "                  "           -   Exclusion: Beaver Dam Wash and        4 Acc, 5 Rej
                                                                                                                      Santa Clara River drainages.
***** End of "Please vote for or against" section 

         7.  Add  Rufous-crowned Sparrow  -  Exclusion:  Washington Co.     9 Acc
           

  
     8.  Add  Ladder-backed Woodpecker Exclusion: Washington Co.   9 Acc
 

         9.  Add  Anna's Hummingbird Exclusion:  Washington Co.     8 Acc, 1 Rej
 

        10.  Add  Common Black-Hawk Exclusion:  Washington Co.   9 Acc
      

        11.  Add  Painted RedstartExclusion:  Zion NP                          8 Acc, 1 Rej

        12.  Add  Vermilion FlycatcherExclusion:  Washington Co.          8 Acc, 1 Rej

 
    Comments and Suggestions:


16 Sep 2025 - Dennis Shirley:

   Yellow-bellied Sapsaucker - Exclusion: Washington Co.

19 Sep 2025 - Mike Schijf :

    Clarification on my Brown-crested Flycatcher and Black-tailed Gnatcatcher votes: My first choice would be the more specific exclusion areas mentioned, but my second choice would be the Washington County exclusion area. In other words, I would rather incorporate the Washington County exclusion area than keep these species off the review list altogether.
 

   (For Proposals with Exclusions, please present the precise wording to be added to the Review List).   
            [See part of the bylaws referring to exclusions - Section B 2 d])]]}